Mystery Witch
Lilly, Ollie and Izzy dress up as ghosts and head out trick-or-treating on Halloween. But the neighbours keep giving them extra sweets for a witch the children cannot see. As the mystery deepens, the three friends think about someone who might be lonely—and leave behind a thoughtful surprise.
Watch
Follow the animated read-along with pictures, words and narration.
Listen
Enjoy the audiobook and let the narration spark imagination.
Read
Read the illustrated story at your own pace.
Copyright © Storyberries
Read Mystery Witch as text
Lilly, Ollie and Izzy decided that their ghostly white sheets were easy for Halloween.
“Okay, we can do scary faces on the sheets…”
Izzy started to make her sheet face scary.
“Brilliant!” she decided, and looked over to Ollie and Lilly’s scary ghostly faces. “Real scary…”
She laughed, and they all put on their sheets over their heads, not forgetting slits so they didn’t fall over.
At the first neighbour’s house they got a good reaction.
“Scary…” Mrs. Bane shook her head and handed over bars of chocolate to the three friends.
“Oh, sorry, I didn’t see the witch behind you…” She handed over another bar of chocolate.
“Witch?” Lilly turned around, but she didn’t see a witch. “We are three ghosts!”
Still, an extra bar of chocolate for an invisible witch wasn’t so bad…
Off they went to the next house with their trick or treat, and you’ll never guess…
Mrs. Day handed over three bags of sweets, then she shouted out, “Don’t forget to share them with your little witch friend! That’s such a good costume!”
The three friends mumbled ‘thank you’ and turned around.
“Where is this witch sneaking around behind us?”
The next house was no different: sweets, and a wave for the shy witch behind them.
“Some kid is following us and getting a good share of the sweets. I wonder who it is…”
But every time they turned around, the mystery witch had disappeared.
“Clever idea…” Lilly said aloud. “Just follow the trick or treaters and get some sweets, too.”
Izzy was thoughtful.
“Maybe she hasn’t got anybody to go with her, this mystery witch.”
The others nodded. The mystery witch was certainly following them, and jumping out of sight before they knew who she was.
When they got back home – much later, and with lots of treats – Lilly, Ollie and Izzy had fun sharing out their sweets and chocolates.
“And what about the mystery witch?” Ollie puzzled. “We got extra because of her…”
“Yes,” Lilly laughed. “We got extra because of her! She should get a share…”
So the children put a few sweets and some chocolates in small pile on a plate. Izzy wrote a note:
Your share, whoever you are- Mystery Witch!
They placed it outside the front door.
Later, Mum organised some Halloween games and a creepy film.
Lilly laughed. “We had our own creepy mystery! A mystery witch was stalking us…”
The next morning, as expected, they slept late, and the sweets and chocolate were gone from the plate…
“Ooops…”
Izzy turned a tiny bit pale as she picked up the note from the empty plate…
“There’s a message…”
And so there was.
THANK YOU…SEE YOU NEXT YEAR!
was scrawled in spidery red letters on the note!
Buy the Paperback
Enjoy a screen-free book to share and reread.

PS: Your support means the world to us! When you make a purchase through an Amazon link, we may earn a small commission at no additional cost to you. This helps us spread the magic of free stories to children across the globe. Thank you for being a part of the Storyberries family!
Explore the story
Context
Explore the ideas, feelings and learning behind the story.
“Mystery Witch” is a modern illustrated Halloween story about three friends who make ghost costumes and visit neighbours for treats. Each neighbour appears to see a witch behind them, creating a repeated puzzle: the adults can see someone whom the children cannot.
Repetition and dialogue encourage children to predict what might happen next and distinguish what characters say from what the three friends observe. The ending does not identify the witch, leaving room for different interpretations of the playful mystery.
Izzy imagines that the stranger may be alone. Instead of keeping all the extra sweets, the friends leave a share and a note. Their decision offers an everyday starting point for talking about kindness, fairness and including people who may feel left out.
Vocabulary
Discover useful new words and what they mean.
- Ghostly
- Looking or feeling like a ghost.
- Slits
- Narrow openings, such as the gaps made so the children could see through their costumes.
- Invisible
- Impossible to see, even if someone thinks it is there.
- Mumbled
- Spoke quietly or unclearly.
- Sneaking
- Moving quietly to avoid being noticed.
- Creepy
- Making you feel a little nervous or spooked.
- Scrawled
- Written quickly or roughly.
- Spidery
- Thin and uneven, like the legs of a spider.
Discussion questions
Use the story to spark thoughtful, imaginative conversations.
Friendship
- Why did Lilly, Ollie and Izzy decide to go trick-or-treating together?
- How do the three friends react when the neighbours mention a witch?
- What changes when the friends listen to Izzy’s idea about the stranger?
Kindness
- Why does Izzy wonder whether the mystery witch is alone?
- Which small actions in the story show care for someone else?
- What kind surprise could you leave for another person?
Sharing
- Why do the children think the mystery witch deserves some sweets?
- How do Lilly, Ollie and Izzy decide what to leave on the plate?
- How would you share treats fairly with a friend who had none?
Inclusion
- What might make the mystery witch reluctant to join the group?
- How might the children invite someone shy to join their Halloween fun?
- What can you do to help someone feel welcome during a celebration?
Frequently Asked Questions
Helpful answers for parents and teachers.
What happens in “Mystery Witch”?
Lilly, Ollie and Izzy go trick-or-treating in homemade ghost costumes. At several houses, neighbours insist a witch is following them and give the children extra sweets for her. The friends never manage to spot their mysterious companion. When they get home, they leave her a share, and a surprising note appears the following morning. It is a playful addition to our Halloween stories for kids.
Why can the neighbours see a witch when the children cannot?
The neighbours repeatedly refer to a witch standing behind the three ghosts, but whenever Lilly, Ollie and Izzy turn around, she has vanished. The story never explains how she hides or whether anything magical is happening. That gap is the central mystery. You can ask children what clues suggest a real costumed child, and what clues leave room for imagination.
Is the mystery witch’s identity ever revealed?
No. The children find that the sweets they left outside have disappeared, and the note now contains a message thanking them and promising to see them next year. They still do not meet the visitor. That open ending invites children to suggest their own explanations without requiring one correct answer. It also keeps the story light rather than turning the witch into a frightening character.
Why do the friends leave sweets outside their door?
The extra treats were given partly for the unseen witch, so Lilly, Ollie and Izzy decide she ought to receive a share. Izzy has also wondered whether the stranger has nobody to celebrate with. They put sweets and chocolates on a plate with a note. This is a concrete example of sharing even when a person is not present to thank you.
Is this Halloween story likely to frighten sensitive children?
The story features ghost costumes, an unseen follower, a creepy film and a mysterious handwritten note, but no violent scenes. Its suspense is mainly playful and ends with a thank-you message. Some children may still find the idea of being followed unsettling. For a sensitive listener, preview the illustrations and pause to talk about costume play, pretend scares and what the children can actually see.
How does the story encourage prediction and inference?
The same pattern happens at several houses: an adult mentions a witch, the children look around, and nobody is there. This repetition gives early readers a chance to notice clues and revise guesses. Pause after Mrs. Bane or Mrs. Day speaks, and ask what the children might discover at the next house. Revisit those ideas when the final note appears.
What does trick-or-treating mean in this story?
Lilly, Ollie and Izzy visit neighbours in ghost costumes on Halloween and receive sweets or chocolate. The neighbours admire their costumes and talk to them, which creates the mystery when they mention an extra visitor. Readers unfamiliar with the custom may appreciate a simple explanation beforehand: children wear costumes and call at participating homes for treats, ideally accompanied by a responsible adult.
How could teachers use “Mystery Witch” in a classroom?
Read the book aloud and make a simple evidence chart with two columns: what the neighbours say and what the three friends actually see. Invite pupils to predict who the witch could be, then compare their ideas with the final note. The repeated encounters and vivid costume illustrations also suit sequencing activities, expressive reading, character dialogue and short creative-writing endings.
What kindness activity could follow the story?
Ask children to design a friendly note for someone who might be feeling left out, without giving away personal information or leaving gifts for strangers unsupervised. They could instead share a classroom treat or create a welcome card for a new pupil. Connect the activity to the three friends choosing to think about the mystery witch’s feelings. More kindness stories can extend the conversation.
Where can children find similar light-hearted witch stories?
The Storyberries witches collection is a useful place to explore stories that use witch characters in different ways. “Mystery Witch” is unusual because the witch is never seen by the three children, and the ending stays unresolved. When choosing another story, check its specific description and pictures, since some witch tales may be more frightening or complex than this one.
Credits
Meet the people who brought Mystery Witch to life.
Written by: Andrea Kaczmarek
Illustrated by: Faishal Aziz
Edited, designed and narrated by: Jade Maitre
Music by Kevin MacLeod (incompetech.com): “Olde Timey”, “Lively Lumpsucker”, “Petulant March”, “Music Box Theme”, “Graveyard Shift” and “Enchanted Valley”. Licensed under Creative Commons Attribution 4.0.

Copyright © Storyberries
